Lift the Gift People, not purses.

Fundraising consulting for nonprofits

Lift the giver.
Lift the gift.

We pair proven fundraising practice with AI systems and simple processes, so first gifts become second gifts and long-time givers grow. Then we hand your team the system, so it keeps working after we leave.

Free review and free 15-minute call. Engagements from $12K. Or get the free library →

Our philosophy

People,
not purses.

Donors are people with a passion for your mission.

Donors aren't wallets to tap. They care about the same mission you do. That's how we work: we build relationships first, and the systems around them, so every donor is known, thanked and invited to do more.

Everything we do starts here.

The leak

Most fundraising plans chase the next new donor. The donors you already have slip out the back.

A first gift is a beginning, not a finish line. When nobody plans the thank-you, the follow-up and the second ask, good people drift away and you spend next year replacing them.

Services

Every donor has more than one gift in them.

We work on the whole climb, from the first yes to the gifts that grow year after year.

01

The first gift

Acquisition built to keep

Bring in new donors who care about your mission, and set them up for a second gift from day one.

The system: An AI-drafted, human-edited welcome and thank-you sequence, sent within 48 hours of every first gift.

  • Giving page and first-gift review
  • Welcome path for new donors
  • Where your new donors come from
02

The second gift

Retention on the calendar

The second gift is when a donor decides to stay. We plan the thank-you, the follow-up and the first real conversation.

The system: An automated call list each week of who is in their second-gift window.

  • Thank-you and stewardship plan
  • Second-ask timing and wording
  • A simple watch list of who's cooling
03

The growing gift

Lift the givers who stayed

Your long-time donors often have room to do more if someone asks well. We find who's ready and help your team prepare the ask.

The system: AI flags upgrade-ready donors from their giving history, and a person decides who to call.

  • Who's ready to give more
  • Upgrade and monthly-giving asks
  • Conversation guides for your team
04

AI in the toolbox

Time back for your people

We set up AI tools that draft thank-you notes, tidy the donor file and flag who needs a call. AI writes the draft. A person sends it.

The system: We set up and train your staff on the tools you already pay for, with written prompts and checklists.

  • Tool setup in the systems you use
  • Prompts and templates for your team
  • Training so it sticks after we leave

First gift to lifelong giver

How it works

Explore. Plan. Build. Install.

1

Explore

We look at what a donor sees, how a gift moves through your office, who gave, who stayed, who went quiet, and which tools you already pay for.

2

Plan

We name the donors you can't afford to lose, the ones ready to give more, what to say to each of them and when, and which work AI can take off your plate.

3

Build

We build it with you: new thank-yous, new asks, and a weekly look at your donor file, with AI doing the drafting and sorting and your people doing the caring.

4

Install

We put the system in place: workflows, prompts, checklists and a simple dashboard, written down and tested with your team, so your people can run it without us in the room.

How we use AI

AI helps. People decide.

AI does the drafting, sorting and reminding. Your people do the caring. Here is how we keep it that way.

  • People stay in charge. AI helps with the work. Your team makes every decision about every donor.
  • A human reviews every donor message. Nothing goes to a donor until a person has read it and made it theirs.
  • Donor data stays in your own systems. We work inside your existing systems and tools you have approved.
  • No donor data trains public models. Names and gift details are never used to train public AI models.
  • Written process docs, handed over. You keep the prompts, checklists and steps, so the system is yours.

Pricing

Start free. Engagements from $12K.

Every engagement has a flat fee, a written scope and an end date. We never charge a percentage of money raised. Everything is done remotely by default.

Start here · Free

Second Gift Review: Who to Call This Month

Free about 3 reviews a week

In about two weeks, you get a short, plain read of what happens after someone's first gift, plus the first donors to call. It's not a sales pitch in disguise. At the end we tell you which engagement fits, if any.

  • Your first-to-second gift rate for last year's new donors, if your data allows it
  • Your thank-you letter, marked up: what to keep, cut and add
  • The 3 fixes that matter most, in order
  • A sort of your first-time donors: who to call or write this month, and why
  • A recording of the 45-minute video readout with you

William does every review himself, so there are only about 3 spots a week. December's first-time donors are in their second-gift window right now.

Engagement · 90 days

First to Second Gift

$15,000

Bring first-time donors back for a second gift. You keep a welcome series, a weekly second-gift call list, and a written checklist your team runs every week.

Engagement · 90 days

Lift the Long-Time Giver

$15,000

Thank, know and invite the people who have given for years, so their gifts and their connection to your mission grow. You keep an upgrade-ready donor list that refreshes from your giving history, plus conversation guides.

Engagement · 60 days

AI Without the Mess

$12,000

A clean donor file plus AI set up on two fundraising tasks, with clear rules for protecting donor data. You keep the prompts, the checklists and the written steps for your staff.

Ongoing · 6-month contract

Steady Hand

$2,000 a month

A monthly read of your donor file, review of appeals and thank-yous before they go out, two calls a month and a quarterly board update. We keep your system tuned, and your prompts and checklists current. A good first step for small nonprofits.

Our guarantee

Useful by Day 30, or You Don't Pay.

Give us your donor data and show up for the sessions. If at our Day-30 review you don't find the work useful, tell us in writing by Day 35. We'll refund every dollar you've paid, cancel the rest, and you keep everything we've delivered so far. No argument.

It covers the first 30 days of any engagement and the first month of Steady Hand. It applies when you send the agreed data within 5 business days of kickoff, your lead joins the kickoff, the Day-30 review and at least 3 of the first 4 calls, and you answer our questions within 3 business days. One guarantee per organization. "Useful" is your call. We promise the work is useful to you, not that it will raise a set amount.

Made for small nonprofits too

Installment options

Prices are the same for every nonprofit, and we offer installment plans so a small team can spread the cost. Paying in full earns a free month of Steady Hand afterward.

We accept check or ACH.

In-person add-ons

Remote by default. In person when it helps.

All work is remote by default. In-person sessions are available anywhere in the US, and internationally by request.

  • Board Ask-Ready Session$2,500*
  • Donor Visit Coaching DayWe prep and coach your team for up to 4 donor visits. Your people make every ask.$3,000*
  • Staff Training Day$4,000*
  • Thank-a-Thon NightYour board and staff make the calls. Thank-yous only, no ask.$1,500*

*Plus travel costs. William coaches and preps. Your staff or board make every ask, and William never asks a donor for money or handles gifts, checks or donor funds.

About

Meet William and Emma Bortins.

We started Lift the Gift because we keep seeing the same pattern: good nonprofits work hard for a first gift, then lose the donor before the second one. The people who gave cared. Nobody kept the conversation going.

We're husband and wife, and partners in the work. William leads every engagement, so you work with us, not a junior team. We use the same AI tools we set up for clients.

Keep the giver. Grow the gift.

William Bortins

Founder, leads client work

Emma Bortins

Partner

Questions

Is this right for us?

Who do you work with?

Nonprofits that already raise money from individuals, through an annual fund, membership, events or monthly giving, and want more of those donors to stay and give again.

What does it cost?

Start free: the Second Gift Review costs nothing, and so does the 15-minute discovery call. Engagements start at $12K: First to Second Gift and Lift the Long-Time Giver are $15,000 over 90 days, and AI Without the Mess is $12,000 over 60 days. Steady Hand is $2,000 a month on a 6-month contract. Small nonprofits can pay in installments. Every fee is flat and agreed in writing, and the guarantee is Useful by Day 30, or You Don't Pay.

Do we need a new CRM or new software?

No. We start with the systems you already have, and we only suggest a new tool if it clearly saves your team time.

Do we need to be tech-savvy?

No. If you can use email and a spreadsheet, you can run what we build. We set everything up with you, write the steps in plain language, and train your team until it feels easy.

Is our donor data safe with AI?

Yes, and we are careful about it. Your donor data stays in your own systems and the tools you approve. We never paste names or gift details into public chatbots, and donor data is never used to train public AI models. A person reviews every message before it goes out.

Will AI replace our fundraisers?

No. AI handles the drafting and sorting so your people have more time for calls, visits and real thank-yous. A person stays in charge of every relationship.

Do you ask our donors for money?

No. We plan, coach and write, and your staff or board make every ask. William never asks a donor for money, never accepts a gift or pledge, and never handles checks, cards or donor funds. Any thank-you call he makes is a thank-you only.

What happens on the discovery call?

In 15 minutes we talk about your donors and where gifts are getting stuck. You'll leave with at least one idea you can use whether or not we work together.

Let's find your next gift, and the one after it.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call. Bring your questions about your donors and we'll work through them together.

Book a free 15-minute call

Prefer email? hello@liftthegift.com